A Brutal Debate for Biden

This transcript was created utilizing speech recognition software program. Whereas it has been reviewed by human transcribers, it could comprise errors. Please assessment the episode audio earlier than quoting from this transcript and e-mail transcripts@nytimes.com with any questions.

From “The New York Instances,” I’m Michael Barbaro. That is “The Every day.”

[MUSIC PLAYING]

Immediately, within the first debate of the 2024 presidential race, Joe Biden hoped to make the case that Donald Trump was unfit to return to the White Home. As an alternative, Biden’s weak efficiency deepened doubts about his personal health for the job.

My colleague, Astead Herndon, a political reporter and a number of “The Run Up,” explains what occurred.

It’s Friday, June 28.

Astead, good night, nearly good morning. By the point we’re completed speaking, it’s undoubtedly going to be Friday morning. Thanks for becoming a member of us at what’s clearly a really tender hour.

No, thanks for having me.

OK. This was at all times going to be a historic debate — two single time period presidents debating one another for an opportunity at a second time period, each selecting to decide out of the standard presidential fee approved debates. We’ve by no means had any of this earlier than. However that’s not, I might wager, what persons are going to recollect about this debate. I believe they’re going to recollect simply how a lot considered one of these candidates brazenly struggled — struggled mightily on the most important potential stage.

Yeah, I imply, there have been some issues I used to be anticipating for tonight’s debate — bitter insults, an incumbent defending a coverage file, the challenger actually attacking it. However one factor I didn’t anticipate was for President Biden to form of stay as much as the caricature of him that has been actually been created during the last six months by Republicans.

And the primary 10 minutes, he was not even only a poor debater, he appeared like a struggling previous man in a approach that, I believe for lots of people, was alarming not even simply in a political sense, however in a private sense. And I believe, within the low bar that had been created for him for tonight’s efficiency, it instantly raised alarm flags that he was not even clearing it.

Effectively, let’s discuss what each Biden and Trump have been making an attempt to do on this debate earlier than we return to the query of how Biden did or didn’t do, and the way Trump did or didn’t do tonight.

For Trump, there may be an electoral opening proper now for him to essentially create a coalition that’s distinctive for a Republican candidate. When you consider the polling or the form of pattern traces that we’ve seen in polling during the last six months, Donald Trump shouldn’t be profitable again the form of conventional Republicans he’s misplaced during the last 4 years. He’s profitable over individuals who have been thought of extra historically Democratic teams or simply extra disaffected voters generally — youthful individuals, individuals of coloration, low earnings people, Black people.

There was a form of progress amongst these margins that’s supplied Trump with this skill to say that, if he can put that collectively in November, there’s an actual distinctive path for him to beat Joe Biden. However that path requires a candidate who’s form of talking in additional disciplined, managed tones than I believe we’re used to Trump speaking. And the Trump marketing campaign was keen to place that greatest foot ahead.

Mm-hmm.

Now, on the Biden aspect, they’ve a basic downside, which is that almost all of People assume the president is simply too previous to serve. And the prospect of an 86-year-old Joe Biden, on the finish of his second time period, frankly, freaks people out. And the Biden marketing campaign’s response to that downside has been, frankly, to decrease it, but additionally say to observe him. And the thought was that if that they had an earlier debate earlier than the conventions, and earlier than the race actually kicked off, they will put a few of these issues to mattress, as we noticed him barely do on the State of the Union earlier this 12 months.

Mm-hmm.

However as we simply talked about, Biden supplied his celebration. No reassurance tonight.

OK. Effectively, take us into the meat of this debate, and let’s discover why this night time ended up being so problematic for Biden. And let’s attempt to perceive whether or not Trump did obtain his purpose of being the form of candidate who can assemble this theoretical broad coalition.

Effectively, let me set the scene.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

Dana Bash and Jake Tapper, the moderators, launched each candidates.

And when Biden walked onto the stage, I imply, it’s beneficiant to name it a stroll. He frankly shuffled in a approach that was solely a visible reminder of the superior age of this president.

And throughout the first couple solutions —

The fast factor that was noticeable was not about what he was saying, however about how he sounded.

Biden’s voice was actually raspy.

It sounded as if he wanted to clear his throat. He was speaking actually softly.

And it made his first couple of solutions nearly incoherent.

After which we received to 1 reply that was actually incoherent —

— and finally ended up trailing off such that it turned clear that this was not somebody who was totally in charge of their presence in the meanwhile. And that actually set the tone for Biden’s efficiency all through the entire debate.

Proper. This was the second, if we’re being trustworthy, the place everybody in politics and political journalism’s telephones simply began exploding with textual content messages, all of them saying some model of, gosh, this debate goes actually fairly badly for President Biden. And I stated, to your level about what he was searching for to do and the assurances he was making an attempt to offer individuals in his celebration and past his celebration, he was not giving these assurances in any respect.

Yeah. Let me learn you some stay textual content messages I received from Democrats in these first 10 minutes. One says, “I believe you must query critically whether or not he may even make it to the tip of this night time.” One other says, “Man, this simply doesn’t really feel good to observe.” I imply, it was an instantaneous sense of panic that was spreading among the many celebration.

And I believe it’s as a result of, usually, these debates have an air of optics and showmanship. However for Biden and his form of political problem, it was actually about that sense of vitality and about that sense of command of stage as a result of the query of age has been so circling round his candidacy.

And so for him to instantly come out with a each presentation and a solution that was frankly not substantive and onerous to comply with, it despatched the issues to the roof. Issues went from 0 to 100 very quick, partially as a result of I believe that’s what individuals have been coming in seeing as a baseline for him and he very instantly stumbled. I might make an analogy to an Olympic hurdler, the place on the first hurdle he fell.

Donald Trump, alternatively, doesn’t appear to have misplaced his edge — that turns into very clear from the start of the talk — and as an alternative is displaying his typical swagger, in addition to his typical challenges with the information.

Yeah, completely. To the extent that Donald Trump could be centered on coverage, he got here out in that mode at present.

We all know that the marketing campaign actually desires to deal with three issues — inflation, immigration, and crime.

And you would see Trump actually returning to these within the early form of 10, quarter-hour.

He repeatedly tied Biden to rising costs, and tried to border the economic system that he stewarded as president as considerably higher than the one which we’re experiencing now.

He framed the nation as safer 4 years in the past than what we’re experiencing now.

You might see him making an attempt to comply with by means of on the form of traditional premise of a re-election marketing campaign the place the challenger actually tries to ask the query, are you higher off than you have been 4 years in the past? And so we received the Donald Trump model of that tonight. However we needs to be clear, it’s infused with plenty of his typical set of falsehoods, as we’ve come to anticipate from him.

And what struck me was — for all of the exaggerations and a few of the falsehoods in what Trump was saying — the distinction between his swagger and his presentation and Biden’s turned probably the most pronounced a part of this backwards and forwards.

Yeah. I believe you’re proper that Trump sounded and felt slightly extra, dare we are saying, presidential than Biden in these first 10 minutes. However the bar was on the ground, as a result of the president got here out with such, I believe, a surprising degree of incoherence that it made Donald Trump — the Donald Trump we’ve seen spew falsehoods, conspiracies, unhingedness at each flip — it made him look like the one that form of had their geese in a row.

And in a form of crystallizing second of this interplay —

— after considered one of Biden’s extra meandering solutions, Trump responds with a quip that actually stated what everybody was pondering.

— saying that, I don’t know what Biden stated on the finish of the sentence and I don’t know if he does both.

Mm-hmm.

It seems like a robust subject for Biden on this a part of the talk was going to be abortion —

— and the moderators deliver it up. And it felt like low hanging fruit — a possibility for Biden accountable Trump for the autumn of Roe versus Wade and rating some actual factors on the board. But it surely didn’t really feel like that’s what occurred.

No, it didn’t. And I believe that speaks to the purpose that got here by means of throughout this debate, that it was constantly not the message, it was the messenger. Abortion has been a politically potent subject for Democrats, and one thing that folk have been searching for Biden to talk to straight.

And he form of botched that framing.

He was making an attempt to seemingly make an analogy about trimesters that didn’t actually come by means of very clearly. And in order that, I believe, was a second the place, when the moderator introduced it up, you’d really feel Democrats assume, OK, that is one thing which may play higher for us than the economic system or immigration. However, like plenty of issues on this debate, Biden simply didn’t appear to place it collectively that effectively.

Finally, on this first half of the talk, issues begin to get a bit extra private, and so they begin to get a bit nastier between these two candidates who clearly don’t like one another in any respect. And apparently, given your framing of would Trump reasonable a few of his excesses, it was Biden who went there first.

Yeah, it was. And we should always put the background right here. There was earlier reporting that Donald Trump had referred to as fallen troopers “suckers and losers” whereas touring a navy gravesite.

And that’s what Biden was referring to, framing Trump as somebody who has constantly disrespected veterans.

However Biden plans on saying —

After which seems to Trump and says —

— you’re the sucker. You’re the loser.

Mm-hmm.

And I believed, for me, this mirrored the Biden marketing campaign technique of wanting to attract Trump out to sort deliver out, let’s say, a extra chaotic model of him that was much less caught to the coverage script. And so I used to be this second to see, OK, how was Trump going to answer this.

He denied form of making the “suckers and losers” comment about useless troopers. However he didn’t form of reply on the non-public degree by which Biden was making an attempt to attract him out to.

He reframed the dialog about commander in chief to be in regards to the form of international instability that has occurred below Biden’s watch.

That is when he mentions the form of Afghanistan withdrawal —

— and form of begins framing the world is extra typically unsafe below Biden than it was below Trump.

Now, definitely, that’s completed in a form of Trumpian approach. But it surely was an instance of him, not less than at that second, probably not assembly Biden within the mud and making an attempt to remain centered on what I believe was his marketing campaign’s purpose on this night time, which was to current him as somebody making a coverage first problem to Biden quite than a private one.

Proper. And what appears to occur for the following 10 or quarter-hour within the debate is that Biden retains making an attempt to get below Trump’s pores and skin, and actually make the case that there’s nothing about him that makes him match to be president.

Yeah. You might really feel President Biden making an attempt to attract out the extra loopy, chaotic aspect of Donald Trump. Among the assaults have been lighter.

Issues like calling him a whiner, for instance.

At one level, he identified the allegations that Donald Trump had intercourse with a porn star whereas his spouse was pregnant.

And at one other level —

— he talked about probably the most severe, I believe, of the political allegations, which is the concept Donald Trump, as convicted felon, is unfit to be president. And you would see Trump bodily wince when the phrases felon have been stated out loud, which I believe is reflective to only how a lot that label actually stings him.

When he talks about January 6, it turns into very clear that he’s making an attempt to obfuscate his personal function.

Trump goes right into a soliloquy about, oh, January 6 —

— fully really diverting the query that was at hand, which is did Donald Trump encourage a mob that struck on the coronary heart of democracy.

And in order that’s the form of push and pull that we have been seeing play out on the stage, which is that definitely Trump was participating in his regular degree of form of dodges and falsehoods. But it surely was coming off, I believe, extra efficiently than some anticipated, partially as a result of Biden was simply ineffective in touchdown a few of these assaults.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

We’ll be proper again.

So, Astead, the second half of the talk begins with a query that feels fairly central to what you described as Trump’s technique of making an attempt to construct this greater coalition that exists in principle that he’s making an attempt to make actual in November. And it’s a query the moderators ask of Biden, and why he appears to have disillusioned Black America.

Yeah, and also you’re proper. Biden is aware of that Black voters are an overwhelmingly Democratic constituency. And theoretically, if these people got here dwelling to assist him, it wouldn’t be a lot more durable to see the trail for Donald Trump’s victory.

And so he tries to offer slightly two-part reply right here —

— each acknowledging that Black voters are proper to really feel some disappointment in Democrats, whereas additionally pointing to some issues his administration has completed to offer assist for these communities.

And also you hear Trump saying that none of these issues are mattering as a result of inflation is hurting Black communities extra —

— and likewise that immigration is taking what Trump dubs, quote unquote, “Black jobs.” Now, I’m not precisely certain what Black jobs are. However we might guess that Trump right here is making an attempt to imply that an inflow of immigration has harm particularly Black communities greater than different ones.

That’s, once more, Trump hitting that three-pronged message in a single — inflation, immigration, and crime. And people issues are all wrapped up in that reply. And it’s actually the pitch that Trump is giving to Black voters.

So that is Trump executing on the technique that you just talked about him desirous to execute on on this debate, which is discovering a approach of interesting to this group of voters, historically Democratic by means of and thru, who’re intrigued by him and may come to him on this election. He’s threading a sophisticated needle in searching for their votes. He’s seeming to succeed a bit.

Sure and no. As a result of I additionally assume this reply was an actual reminder of how Donald Trump shouldn’t be a pure communicator on these points, and admittedly, usually seems like an unhinged man himself. Whether or not or not it’s “Black jobs,” quote, unquote, or in his subsequent reply about local weather change, there have been some moments on this debate that undoubtedly reminded us of the Donald Trump who misplaced 4 years in the past, frankly, as a result of many of the nation did discover him unacceptable.

When requested about local weather change, he doesn’t reply the query in any respect.

After which, after a follow-up by the moderators, he goes on a form of traditional Trump soliloquy —

— about how I need completely immaculate clear water, and I need completely clear air —

— how we’ve one of the best h2o. It’s the Trump of the memes that frankly, I believe, will get him additional away from who he desires to be if he’s going to cross his personal form of normal by way of reaching totally different people for November.

Proper. What saved putting me on this second half, as on this local weather change trade, is simply how constantly Trump shouldn’t be answering the questions that the moderators are asking him.

Oh, completely. Whether or not or not it’s questions on baby care, Medicare, whether or not it’s questions on opioids, these are core points individuals cared about. And Trump nearly by no means responded to the moderators’ direct questions on these issues. He nearly at all times stayed in these three buckets that have been clearly his focus to assault Biden — economic system, immigration, crime.

It’s round right here that the moderators flip to a query that has been on everybody’s thoughts at this level all night time, which is the candidates’ age. And so they begin with Biden, whose age has been fairly current on this debate. So inform us how that unfolds.

Yeah. The moderators put to the candidates straight the query about whether or not these are individuals who even bodily or mentally can lead the nation for the following 4 years. And Biden, I’ve to say, didn’t encourage a lot confidence.

He begins off by saying he spent half his profession being criticized for a way younger he was. After which he goes on to say that it is best to decide him for the job that he’s completed in workplace.

He’s saying to guage him by what he did quite than how previous he’s. The issue is that the primary a part of the talk was so outlined by how inarticulate he was, that the query of age had been all of a sudden already answered and he had flunked that check. Now, Trump responds in a perhaps much more ridiculous vogue —

— speaking in regards to the psychological acuity check that he has taken —

— and specializing in his personal golf recreation —

Proper.

— saying that he can hit a ball 50 yards, and that that’s an instance of how he feels in bodily fine condition, akin to 25 and 30 years in the past.

Proper. And that is once we enter the strangest second, I’ve to assume, in presidential debate historical past — two quite previous males wrangling over who has the higher golf recreation.

I’ve to say, this second personally form of bummed me out. There was a 1-minute interval the place the 2 choices to main the nation have been arguing over their golf handicaps.

One thing in regards to the debate about whose golf handicap was higher felt like a distillation of the failure of this debate to essentially present the American individuals with the choices and the form of severe coverage dialogue that the workplace warrants.

Astead, by the tip of this 90-minute debate, it actually felt just like the consuming query that it produced wasn’t a lot about whether or not Donald Trump was going to assemble a coalition that received him the presidency. The burning query gave the impression to be round President Biden and his weak efficiency. And so I need to be sure we finish there, with an understanding of what now occurs due to how Joe Biden carried out, and what it’s going to imply for the remainder of the race.

Yeah. I had come into the talk pondering that the onus was on Donald Trump to show himself as a disciplined challenger who might take what was a polling chance of a broad coalition and make it actual. However frankly, that perception was based mostly on the idea that Joe Biden would clear the baseline of coherence that may make the age query not less than neutralized for the night time. However by the tip of the night time, it turned clear that that wasn’t the place the dialog could be.

I believe that Joe Biden’s efficiency was frankly so disastrous {that a} Democratic celebration freak out that has been effervescent below a lid for months now has now exploded into the open to the purpose the place you’ve his former communications director on tv saying that was a poor efficiency.

Proper. Kate Bedingfield. That struck me too. His former White Home communications director went on TV and stated that was a disappointing debate efficiency from President Biden — one thing Democratic communications administrators don’t usually say on the file moments after a debate ends.

Completely. Additionally, I noticed an interview with Vice President Kamala Harris and Anderson Cooper instantly after the talk the place the Vice President, the cheerleader in chief for the president, stated very explicitly that she wouldn’t deny he had a tough begin, however believes that he received higher on the finish, and saying the final 90 minutes doesn’t erase the final 3 and 1/2 years — an actual acknowledgment of the opening that Biden, frankly, put himself in all through tonight’s debate.

However I received to say, as somebody who has devoted the final 12 months and a half to asking plenty of Democrats questions on how we arrived at an 81-year-old president operating for re-election, they’ve constantly dismissed the overwhelming proof that the majority People thought Biden was too previous to run for a second time period. I introduced that query to them on the DNC —

I bear in mind.

— as they have been making his path to the nomination simpler. And the reply that, frankly, we received on the time was that Donald Trump could be so inherently invalid, none of that may matter. However there was no proof to assist that. That was their very own perception that that may simply change.

After which tonight, not solely did Donald Trump not look like somebody who was fully unfit for the workplace of president, however that Biden was the memed model of himself, the incoherent, falling off a motorbike, TikTok caricature of himself. And I believe now the Democrats are brazenly panicking about what Biden ought to do subsequent, about what the celebration ought to do subsequent, they’ve so much fewer choices at their disposal.

Proper. There may be actually no plan B due to how Democratic leaders dealt with this case for therefore lengthy.

Sure. There isn’t any plan B as a result of they refused to ask the questions that may even result in the creation of a plan B within the lead as much as this. And so there aren’t actually clear options as to what Democrats ought to do going ahead. And that actually, I believe, goes to scare plenty of democrats. As a result of should you’re somebody who desires Joe Biden to be president, plenty of these individuals consider that Donald Trump is a grave hazard to this nation. And the assumption was that Joe Biden was the individual uniquely positioned to cease that from taking place.

As a result of he had completed it 4 years earlier than.

As a result of he had completed it 4 years in the past. However I believe what’s modified from final night time to at present is a realization that really nominating Joe Biden is likely to be the most important threat for the celebration, and be the very factor that makes a second time period of Donald Trump most potential.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

Effectively, Astead, thanks very a lot.

Thanks for having me.

For extra in-depth protection of the 2024 presidential race, try Astead’s present, “The Run Up,” which comes out each Thursday. Yow will discover ‘The Run Up” wherever you pay attention.

[MUSIC PLAYING]

We’ll be proper again.

Right here’s what else you want to know at present. On Thursday, the Supreme Courtroom blew up a landmark authorized settlement between prosecutors and Purdue Pharma the maker of Oxycontin. The settlement would have channeled $6 billion into assuaging the opioid epidemic that Purdue Pharma allegedly performed a significant function in creating. However the settlement relied on a promise to protect members of the Sackler household, that created Purdue Pharma, from future lawsuits. And of their 5 to 4 ruling, the Supreme Courtroom discovered that protect to be unlawful and invalid.

The case was considered one of a number of main rulings on Thursday. In one other determination, the court docket quickly cleared the best way for ladies in Idaho to obtain emergency abortions when their well being is in danger, regardless of a state legislation there all however banning the process. In a 3rd determination, the court docket blocked a federal plan to cut back air air pollution that drifts throughout state traces — a authorized defeat for President Biden.

A fast reminder about this week’s episode of “The Interview.” David Marchese talks with Eddie Murphy about his lengthy profession in comedy, his return to the “Beverly Hills” franchise, and about what it’s wish to make his idol, Richard Pryor, snigger.

Immediately’s episode was produced by Clare Toeniskoetter, Nina Feldman and Shannon Lin. It was edited by Marc Georges, incorporates authentic music by Dan Powell, Mary Marion Lozano, Elisheba Ittoop, and Diane Wong, and was engineered by Chris Wooden and Alyssa Moxley. Our theme music is by Jim Brunberg and Ben Landsverk of Wonderly.

“The Every day” is made by Rachel Quester, Lynsea Garrison, Clare Toeniskoetter, Paige Cowett, Michael Simon Johnson, Brad Fisher, Chris Wooden, Jessica Cheung, Stella Tan, Alexandra Leigh Younger, Lisa Chow, Eric Krupke, Marc Georges, Luke Vander Ploeg. MJ Davis Lin, Dan Powell, Sydney Harper, Michael Benoist, Liz O. Baylen, Asthaa Chaturvedi, Rachelle Bonja, Diana Nguyen, Marion Lozano, Corey Schreppel, Rob Szypko, Elisheba Ittoop, Muge Zadie, Patricia Willens, Rowan Niemisto, Jodi Becker, Riki Novetsky, Nina Feldman, Will Reid, Carlos Prieto, Ben Calhoun, Susan Lee, Lexie Diao, Mary Wilson, Alex Stern, Sophia Lanman, Shannon Lin, Diane Wong, Devin Taylor, Alyssa Moxley, Olivia Natt, Daniel Ramirez, and Brendan Klinkenberg.

Particular because of Lisa Tobin, Sam Dolnick, Paula Szuchman, Larissa Anderson, Julia Simon, Sofia Milan, Mahima Chablani, Elizabeth Davis-Moore, Jeffrey Miranda. Maddie Masiello, Isabella Anderson. Nina Lassam, and Nick Pittman.

That’s it for “The Every day.” I’m Michael Barbaro. See you on Monday.

[MUSIC PLAYING]